How are the stock price scenarios calculated?
A share price is earnings per share (EPS) times the P/E the market pays for them. The scenarios on the forecast page take the EPS analysts expect for the years ahead and multiply it by the P/E range the stock has had before. The answer is three prices for each year: a bear case, a base case and a bull case.
How is each price calculated?
- EPS: the analysts' consensus for each fiscal year that at least 3 analysts estimate, up to 3 years ahead. Two more years follow, marked (extrapolated): they grow at the analysts' rate from the last reported EPS to the last estimate, but at most 15% a year, as few companies grow earnings faster than that for long.
- P/E range: the lowest, the average and the highest of today's P/E and the P/E at the company's last 5 fiscal year ends. A P/E above 60 is left out: it comes from a year when earnings collapsed or were tiny, and says little about what future earnings are worth. A year with a loss is left out too.
- Bear = EPS × the lowest P/E. Base = EPS × the average P/E. Bull = EPS × the highest P/E.
What if the stock's own P/E is no guide?
When fewer than 3 of those P/Es are left (the stock traded above 60, or at a loss, in most of those years), the P/Es of similar companies stand in: US companies in the same industry and of a similar size, again leaving out any above 60. They are used only if their range, on the earnings analysts expect for one of the years, takes in today's price: they must be able to explain what the market pays for the stock now. A chip maker valued like other chip makers passes; a carmaker grouped with retailers and restaurants does not.
When neither works, the page shows no price scenarios and says why. The analysts' EPS estimates are still on the page.
An example
A company earned $5.00 a share last year, and analysts expect $7.00 in three years. That is a growth rate of (7.00 ÷ 5.00)1/3 − 1 = about 11.9% a year, under the 15% limit, so the two extrapolated years are about $7.83 and $8.76. Had analysts expected $10.00 (26% a year), the extrapolated years would grow 15%: $11.50, then about $13.22.
Today the stock trades at a P/E of 22; at its last five year ends it traded at 15, 18, 22, 25 and 30. Its range is 15 to 30, and the average of the six is 22. For the third year, at $7.00 of EPS:
- Bear: 7.00 × 15 = $105
- Base: 7.00 × 22 = $154
- Bull: 7.00 × 30 = $210
How do you read the scenarios?
- The gap between bear and bull comes from the P/E, not from the earnings: it shows how much the price could move if the market paid what it paid at its cheapest or dearest.
- The extrapolated years assume the growth goes on at the same pace. Read them as "if nothing changes", not as a forecast.
- Compare the base case with today's price and with the analysts' price target, which is their own view of the price in 12 months.
Where is it on Arincen?
On a stock's forecast page, such as Apple's forecast page, as a chart and a table of EPS with the three prices for each year. It is free. A note under the table says which P/Es priced them.
What are the limits?
The scenarios are arithmetic on the analysts' estimates, not a prediction and not advice. Estimates change, and a P/E can leave its old range when a company's growth or risk changes for good.
More in Earnings and analysts
What is an earnings surprise?
An earnings surprise is how far a company's reported EPS or revenue came above or below the analysts' average estimate, in percent.
What is the next-day move after earnings?
The next-day move is how much a stock's price changed on the first trading day after an earnings report: how the market took the results.
What is an analyst price target?
A price target is the price an analyst expects a stock to reach in 12 months. Arincen shows the average, high and low targets and the upside to the average.
What is the analyst rating?
The analyst rating sums up what the analysts covering a stock recommend, from strong buy to strong sell, by the share of them rating it a buy.
What are estimate revisions?
Estimate revisions are the changes analysts make to their EPS and revenue forecasts for the years ahead. They show whether expectations are rising or falling.
What is the market waiting for in a report?
The two to four figures investors watch most in a company's next earnings report, each with the number analysts or the company expect, and after the report, whether it came in.
What did management say in the report?
The CEO's and CFO's words in the earnings release, minutes after it is filed, and the earnings call summed up a few hours later: guidance, main topics and analysts' toughest questions.
How is a Wall Street firm's success rate calculated?
A research firm's success rate is the share of its Buy calls that beat the S&P 500 over the next 12 months, and of its Sell calls that did worse, measured on our own prices.