What is the analyst rating?
Each research firm that covers a stock gives it a rating in its own words: Buy, Outperform, Overweight, Neutral, Equal Weight, Underperform, Sell and many more. The analyst rating, or consensus, brings them together into one of five grades: strong buy, buy, hold, sell or strong sell.
How is the consensus worked out?
Arincen counts each firm once, at its latest rating from the last 12 months, and sorts the firms' words into the five grades: Outperform, Overweight and Accumulate count as a buy; Neutral, Equal Weight and Market Perform as a hold; Underperform, Underweight and Reduce as a sell. Then:
- Strong buy: 80% or more of the analysts rate it a buy or a strong buy, with at least 3 ratings.
- Buy: more than half do.
- Strong sell and sell: the same rules on the sell side.
- Hold: neither side has more than half.
Example: 20 analysts cover a stock; 4 rate it a strong buy, 13 a buy and 3 a hold. That is 17 of 20, or 85% buy, so the consensus is a strong buy. With 12 buys and 8 holds (60%), it would be a buy.
How do you read the rating?
- Analysts rate far more stocks a buy than a sell, so a buy is the usual case. A hold or a sell consensus stands out more.
- The number of analysts matters. A strong buy from 3 analysts says less than one from 30.
- Ratings change slowly and often follow the price. The trend over months, and the latest upgrades and downgrades, tell you more than one snapshot.
- A rating is an opinion, not a guarantee, and not advice made for you.
How does Arincen show the analyst rating?
On a stock's forecast page, such as Apple's forecast page:
- A gauge from strong sell to strong buy, its needle in the consensus grade, with the number of analysts.
- How many analysts rate it a buy, a hold or a sell, as bars: a strong buy counts as a buy, a strong sell as a sell.
- How analysts rate the stock, month by month: the buy, hold and sell counts for each of the last 12 months, each firm at its latest rating of the year before (strong buys count as buys, strong sells as sells).
- The analysts' upgrades, downgrades and price targets: the latest two are free. Every move of the past year, firm by firm, with the price on the day, is part of Arincen Plus (and Premium).
In the stock screener, the Analysts Covering filter is free, while Analyst Rating is a Plus filter. The Strong Buy Stocks list ranks the large companies that 80% or more of their analysts, ten or more, rate a buy. It is a Plus list: everyone sees its first two stocks.
What is it related to?
The rating comes with each firm's analyst price target, so read the two together: a buy with a small upside to the average target says something different from a buy with a large one.
More in Earnings and analysts
What is an earnings surprise?
An earnings surprise is how far a company's reported EPS or revenue came above or below the analysts' average estimate, in percent.
What is the next-day move after earnings?
The next-day move is how much a stock's price changed on the first trading day after an earnings report: how the market took the results.
What is an analyst price target?
A price target is the price an analyst expects a stock to reach in 12 months. Arincen shows the average, high and low targets and the upside to the average.
What are estimate revisions?
Estimate revisions are the changes analysts make to their EPS and revenue forecasts for the years ahead. They show whether expectations are rising or falling.
What is the market waiting for in a report?
The two to four figures investors watch most in a company's next earnings report, each with the number analysts or the company expect, and after the report, whether it came in.
How are the stock price scenarios calculated?
Bear, base and bull prices for the years ahead: the analysts' EPS estimates times the lowest, average and highest P/E of the stock today and at its last five year ends, or of its peers.
What did management say in the report?
The CEO's and CFO's words in the earnings release, minutes after it is filed, and the earnings call summed up a few hours later: guidance, main topics and analysts' toughest questions.
How is a Wall Street firm's success rate calculated?
A research firm's success rate is the share of its Buy calls that beat the S&P 500 over the next 12 months, and of its Sell calls that did worse, measured on our own prices.