How is a Wall Street firm's success rate calculated?

Every Wall Street research firm on Arincen has a success rate: how often its Buy and Sell calls turned out right. We measure it ourselves, on our own daily prices, with one open rule, so you can see which firms' calls were worth following.

When is a call right?

  • A Buy is right when the stock did better than the S&P 500 (SPY) over the 12 months after the call.
  • A Sell is right when the stock did worse than the S&P 500 over those 12 months.
  • Hold calls are not measured: they say neither that a stock will beat the market nor that it will lag it.

A stock is measured from its last close on or before the day of the call, adjusted for splits, before dividends. Beating the S&P 500, not just rising, is the test: in a year when the whole market rose 20%, a Buy that rose 5% was not a good call.

Which calls count?

The calls a firm made over the three years that ended a year ago, the newest whose 12 months are over, on the stocks we cover. A call made today is judged in 12 months: until then it shows on the firm's page and on the stock's forecast page, but not in the success rate.

How are the firms ranked?

A firm needs at least 30 calls measured to be ranked. The firms are not ranked by their success rate alone, because a few lucky calls can look better than many good ones: 20 right calls of 30 (67%) prove less than 60 of 100 (60%).

So we rank by the success rate a firm's number of calls makes us 95% sure of: 50.2% for 60 right of 100, but 48.8% for 20 of 30, so the firm with 100 calls ranks higher. Firms that tie are ranked by how much their calls beat the S&P 500 on average (a Sell counts the other way).

What is a firm's portfolio?

What you would have earned by following a firm's Buy calls: each stock bought at the close of the day of its Buy call and held until the firm cut it to Hold or Sell, or until 12 months after its last Buy, all stocks in equal amounts, beside the S&P 500 (SPY) over the same days. It covers the last five years, only on the stocks we cover today, so stocks that fell away are left out and the returns can look better than they were.

What does Arincen show?

  • Wall Street research firms: the firms ranked by their success rate, the top three, and the newest upgrades and downgrades.
  • Each firm's page: its success rate year by year, how much its calls beat the S&P 500, its calls, and the stocks it rates now.
  • On a stock's forecast page: each firm's call, with the firm's rank and success rate.
  • With Plus: each firm's portfolio against the S&P 500, every stock it holds and all its calls, and the most upgraded stocks list.

A firm's success rate tells how its past calls did. It is not a signal to buy or sell.

Related terms: analyst rating, analyst price target.

More in Earnings and analysts

What is an earnings surprise?

An earnings surprise is how far a company's reported EPS or revenue came above or below the analysts' average estimate, in percent.

What is the next-day move after earnings?

The next-day move is how much a stock's price changed on the first trading day after an earnings report: how the market took the results.

What is an analyst price target?

A price target is the price an analyst expects a stock to reach in 12 months. Arincen shows the average, high and low targets and the upside to the average.

What is the analyst rating?

The analyst rating sums up what the analysts covering a stock recommend, from strong buy to strong sell, by the share of them rating it a buy.

What are estimate revisions?

Estimate revisions are the changes analysts make to their EPS and revenue forecasts for the years ahead. They show whether expectations are rising or falling.

What is the market waiting for in a report?

The two to four figures investors watch most in a company's next earnings report, each with the number analysts or the company expect, and after the report, whether it came in.

How are the stock price scenarios calculated?

Bear, base and bull prices for the years ahead: the analysts' EPS estimates times the lowest, average and highest P/E of the stock today and at its last five year ends, or of its peers.

What did management say in the report?

The CEO's and CFO's words in the earnings release, minutes after it is filed, and the earnings call summed up a few hours later: guidance, main topics and analysts' toughest questions.