What is an earnings surprise?

Before a company reports its quarterly results, the analysts who follow it publish estimates of its earnings per share (EPS) and its revenue. The average of those estimates is the consensus. When the results come out, the gap between the reported figure and the consensus is the earnings surprise.

  • Beat: the result came in above the estimate.
  • Miss: it came in below.
  • In line: it matched the estimate exactly.

How is the earnings surprise calculated?

The surprise is the reported figure minus the estimate, divided by the estimate, in percent:

Surprise = (reported − estimate) ÷ estimate × 100

Say analysts expected EPS of $2.00 and the company reported $2.20. The surprise is (2.20 − 2.00) ÷ 2.00 = +10%, a beat. If they expected revenue of $50 billion and it came in at $49 billion, the revenue surprise is −2%, a miss.

When the estimate is a loss, its size is used without the minus sign, so a smaller loss than expected counts as a beat: an expected loss of $0.50 a share against a reported loss of $0.40 is a surprise of +20%.

How do you read a beat or a miss?

  • Small beats are common. Companies guide analysts toward figures they expect to clear, so a beat of a few percent is often what the market already expected. A miss usually stands out more.
  • EPS and revenue tell different stories. EPS can beat through cost cuts, a lower tax rate, buybacks or a one-off gain. A revenue beat says more about demand.
  • The price can fall on a beat. Investors also weigh the company's outlook for the coming quarters, so the reaction does not always follow the surprise. See the next-day move.
  • The estimate moves too. Analysts often cut their estimates in the weeks before a report, which makes a beat easier. See estimate revisions.

A surprise says nothing about whether the stock is cheap or expensive.

How does Arincen show the earnings surprise?

On a stock's earnings page, such as Apple's earnings page, every report since the first one our data provider has is listed with its EPS and revenue, the analysts' average estimate for each, and the surprise in percent. The top of the page gives the last EPS surprise and the last revenue surprise. A report still to come shows only its estimates.

The beat record counts how many reports beat the estimate, for EPS and for revenue (for example 30 / 40). A result that only matches the estimate is not counted as a beat. Beside it are the average EPS surprise over the last 12 reports, and a sentence on how far off the estimates usually were: the average size of the surprise, a beat and a miss counting alike.

In the stock screener, the Last EPS Surprise filter and column find stocks by their most recent surprise.

What should you watch out for?

  • Estimates close to zero produce huge percentages: an estimate of $0.02 against a reported $0.05 is a +150% surprise.
  • Adjusted figures. Analysts and companies often work with adjusted earnings that leave out one-off items, so the EPS compared here can differ from the EPS on the income statement.
  • One quarter is one quarter. The beat record over several years says more than a single result.

More in Earnings and analysts

What is the next-day move after earnings?

The next-day move is how much a stock's price changed on the first trading day after an earnings report: how the market took the results.

What is an analyst price target?

A price target is the price an analyst expects a stock to reach in 12 months. Arincen shows the average, high and low targets and the upside to the average.

What is the analyst rating?

The analyst rating sums up what the analysts covering a stock recommend, from strong buy to strong sell, by the share of them rating it a buy.

What are estimate revisions?

Estimate revisions are the changes analysts make to their EPS and revenue forecasts for the years ahead. They show whether expectations are rising or falling.

What is the market waiting for in a report?

The two to four figures investors watch most in a company's next earnings report, each with the number analysts or the company expect, and after the report, whether it came in.

How are the stock price scenarios calculated?

Bear, base and bull prices for the years ahead: the analysts' EPS estimates times the lowest, average and highest P/E of the stock today and at its last five year ends, or of its peers.

What did management say in the report?

The CEO's and CFO's words in the earnings release, minutes after it is filed, and the earnings call summed up a few hours later: guidance, main topics and analysts' toughest questions.

How is a Wall Street firm's success rate calculated?

A research firm's success rate is the share of its Buy calls that beat the S&P 500 over the next 12 months, and of its Sell calls that did worse, measured on our own prices.