How does Arincen work out a stock's fair value?

What is fair value?

Fair value is an estimate of what a share would cost if the market priced the company the way it usually does. It is a yardstick for today's price, not a price target or a prediction.

How is fair value calculated?

The main method uses the company's own P/E history. We take its P/E on every trading day of the last five years: each day's close over the earnings per share (EPS) of the last four quarters reported by then. The median of those readings is its usual P/E. Fair value is the usual P/E times the EPS of the last twelve months. The range is the same EPS at the lowest and the highest P/E of those five years.

For example, a company earning $5 a share with a usual P/E of 20 has a fair value of $100. If its P/E ranged from 14 to 28, the range is $70 to $140. At a price of $90, the shares trade 10% below fair value.

If the company earned much less in part of those years, only the days it earned at least half of today's EPS count, so a P/E swollen by a bad year does not raise the bar.

What if the usual P/E no longer fits the company?

Sometimes the company's history stops describing it: analysts expect EPS growth more than 20 points a year away from its past growth, or the usual P/E would put the value more than 50% away from the price. Then one of two other methods stands in:

  • Growth, for a company analysts expect to grow EPS by 15% a year or more: a P/E equal to that growth (a PEG of 1), at most 25, times the EPS expected over the next twelve months. Range: a PEG of 0.75 to 1.25.
  • Peers: the median P/E of at least three US companies in its industry closest to it in size, times its EPS of the last twelve months. Range: the lowest to the highest peer P/E.

Either one must also land within 50% of the price.

Why are one-off gains taken out?

A large one-off gain, such as a profit on a stake in another company, inflates EPS and would push fair value up. So we compare each quarter's other (non-operating) income with its usual level, the median of the previous five fiscal years. An excess worth 15% or more of the quarter's pretax income is removed, after tax, from the EPS behind fair value. Only gains are removed, never losses: a fair value set too high misleads more. Real estate trusts, whose business is partly selling property, are left as reported, and so is the EPS shown elsewhere.

When does Arincen say "Not reliable"?

  • The company made a loss in one of its last five fiscal years.
  • EPS fell more than 30% in one of the last two fiscal years.
  • Its history no longer fits and neither growth nor peers gives a value close enough to the price.

A loss or a fall stops counting once the latest year's EPS is back above the year before it. With less than three years of P/E history, or a loss today, there is no fair value at all.

Where does Arincen show fair value?

In the header of every US stock page with full financials: the fair value, the price's distance from it and a bar of the range with today's price on it, or "Not reliable" with the reason when you point at it. The Apple stock forecast page shows the bar with the method used. The full P/E history check behind it, on Apple's P/E ratio page, is part of Arincen Plus (and Premium), as are the fair value filter in the stock screener and the below-fair-value tab of the undervalued stocks list. Related terms: P/E ratio, PEG ratio.

More in Stock pages and the Arincen Score