What is a Rule 10b5-1 trading plan?

What is a Rule 10b5-1 plan?

Executives and directors often know things about their company that the public does not, which makes it hard for them to trade its shares without risking a charge of insider trading. Rule 10b5-1, an SEC rule, offers a way: the insider sets up a written plan at a time when they hold no inside information, and a broker then carries out the trades the plan lays down, whatever the insider learns later.

How does a 10b5-1 plan work?

  • The plan fixes the trades ahead: how many shares, at what prices or on which dates, or a formula for them.
  • Under rules in force since 2023, a waiting period must pass before the first trade (for directors and officers, usually at least 90 days), and since 1 April 2023 every Form 4 has a box showing whether the trade was made under such a plan.
  • Companies also report in their quarterly and annual filings when their directors and officers adopt or end a plan.

Example: in March, a CEO adopts a plan to sell 20,000 shares on the first trading day of every month from July. Each of those sales shows on a Form 4 with the 10b5-1 box ticked.

Why does it matter whether a sale was planned?

A sale decided that week can say something about what the insider thinks of the stock. A sale under a plan set up months before mostly says the insider wanted to turn part of their shares into cash on a schedule: for tax, a house, or to hold less of one company. So planned sales usually tell you less than sales decided at the time. The plans can still carry some information: when one was adopted, changed or ended.

How does Arincen tell planned sales from sales decided at the time?

Our data provider does not carry the 10b5-1 box, so Arincen reads it from each Form 4 at the SEC (EDGAR), once per filing. A filing not read yet counts as not planned until it is.

  • On a stock's insiders page, such as Apple's executives and insider trading page, the Insiders buying against selling bars split each period's sales into Sold under a Rule 10b5-1 plan set in advance (the lighter part) and Sold, decided at the time.
  • The Arincen Score checks that insiders were not net sellers over the last 12 months outside 10b5-1 plans: purchases minus the sales not under a plan. Say insiders sold $5 million, $4 million of it under plans, and bought nothing: the balance outside plans is −$1 million and the check fails. Had they also bought $1.5 million, it would pass.
  • The Insider Buying Stocks list and the screener's Insider Buying filter leave out purchases made under a plan. Both are part of Arincen Plus (and Premium).

What is it related to?

A 10b5-1 plan is one kind of insider trading: the legal trades insiders report on Form 4. Read the planned and the unplanned sales side by side, together with any open-market purchases.

More in Insiders and ownership