What is the Shariah stock screen?

What is a Shariah stock screen?

Many Muslim investors want to own only companies whose business and finances fit Islamic rules on interest, debt and prohibited activities. A Shariah screen checks a company against a set of tests to give a first answer. Several standards exist and scholars differ on the details. Arincen follows AAOIFI Shariah Standard No. 21, from the Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Financial Institutions. The result is a financial screen, not a religious ruling.

What are the four tests?

  1. Business activity: the company's main business must not be an excluded activity, such as conventional banking and insurance, alcohol, tobacco or gambling.
  2. Debt to market value: interest-bearing debt must be under 30% of the company's market value.
  3. Interest-bearing cash and investments to market value: under 30%.
  4. Impermissible income to revenue: under 5%.

Example: a software company is worth $100 billion. Its debt is $20 billion (20%, passes), its cash and investments $35 billion (35%, does not pass) and its interest income 2% of revenue (passes). One failed test is enough, so it does not pass the screen. If its share price rose and the company became worth $125 billion, the cash ratio would fall to 28% and it would pass.

What do the verdicts mean?

  • Halal (compliant): all four tests ran and passed.
  • Not halal (not compliant): at least one test failed.
  • Not enough data: no test failed, but one could not be run, usually because the company does not report its interest income separately. The page then says the stock is halal on the AAOIFI tests its figures allow.

How does Arincen run the screen?

  • Business: the company's industry is checked against the excluded activities (banks, insurance, credit services, mortgage lenders, capital markets firms, alcohol makers, tobacco, gambling and casinos).
  • Debt: total debt on the latest quarterly balance sheet, lease liabilities included, against today's market value.
  • Cash: cash plus short- and long-term investments, all counted as interest-bearing (the stricter reading), against today's market value.
  • Income: interest income against revenue over the last four quarters when the company reports it each quarter, or else in the last fiscal year it reported it.

Apple's Shariah page shows the verdict, each test with its figure, limit and result, how to purify the dividend, the screen at each of the last five fiscal year ends, and how the screen works. A Shariah (AAOIFI) badge appears on the stock's pages, and the stock screener has a Shariah Compliant filter and column.

What should you keep in mind?

  • Two tests use the market value, so a verdict can change with the share price, not only with new results.
  • The screen uses the company's own reported figures, which arrive with each quarterly report.
  • Other standards use other limits, or divide by total assets instead of market value, so another screen can reach a different verdict.
  • For a personal ruling, ask a qualified scholar. Related term: dividend purification.

More in Halal stocks